Survey Reports
April 30, 2000

Self Censorship: How Often and Why

PrintEmailShare

Questionnaire

          PEW RESEARCH CENTER AND COLUMBIA JOURNALISM REVIEW
                         SURVEY OF JOURNALISTS
                             FINAL TOPLINE
         FEBRUARY 8 - MARCH 21, 2000 N=287(National and Local)
                         N=90 (Investigative)

1.   What do you feel is the most important problem facing journalism today? (OPEN-END)

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     15  Credibility problem                       15    5    19     15   22    13        23
     10  Coverage should be less sensationalized   13   10    16      7    8     7         9
      8  Corporate ownership                        9   10     8      7    3     9         7
      6  Too much emphasis on costs/profits         6    8     4      7    0     5        13
      6  Competing with other forms of media        8   10     8      4    8     4         4
      3  Reporting accurately/factually             5    0     8      2    8     0         3
      3  Financial cutbacks/budget constraints      4    5     4      3    5     2         1
      3  Making sure coverage is relevant           3    0     4      3    3     4         2
      2  Reporting objectively/fairly               1    0     1      3    3     3         3
      2  Decline in circulation/audience            1    0     1      4    3     4         3
      2  Competition damaging to journalism         2    0     3      2    0     3         1
         Staffing problems/Not enough quality
      2  journalists                                3    0     4      2    3     2         8
      2  Confusion between opinions and reporting   4    3     6      0    0     0         1
      2  Attracting readers/viewers/listeners       0    0     0      3    8     2         1
      2  24 hour/Around the clock competition       1    3     1      2    0     3         3
      2  Ratings take precedence                    0    0     0      3    3     4         1
     25  Other                                     24   42    18     26   27    27        31
     21  No answer                                 20   24    17     22    8    23        11
     37  BUSINESS/FINANCIAL (NET)                  35   37    36     38   35    40        40
         24      Economic pressures(subnet)        23   24    24     25   24    24        32
         11      Competition(subnet)               13   16    13      9   11    11        11
          2      Commercialism (subnet)             0    0     0      5    3     6         1
     27  QUALITY AND STANDARDS (NET)               30   24    34     23   30    23        27
         25      Quality of coverage (subnet)      28   21    31     22   30    21        24
          1      Quality of writing (subnet)        2    3     1      1    0     1         0
          1      Ethics and Standards (subnet)      1    0     2      1    0     1         2
     19  CREDIBILITY/TRUSTWORTHINESS (NET)         18    8    22     19   27    17        24
          4      PUBLIC'S APPETITE                  3    5     2      5    8     4         4


2. Here are some things being talked about in journalism today.  For each one, please say
whether it is having a positive effect on journalism, having a negative effect on
journalism, or isn't having much of an effect.


                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
        a. The increasing number of
           cable news outlets
     52      Positive Effect                       51   63    47     53   46    58        46
     28      Negative Effect                       31   24    33     25   24    24        27
     14      Not Much Effect                       10   13    10     17   24    13        22
      6      Don't Know/Refused                     8   --    10      5    6     5         5
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        b. Television shifting more to a
           magazine format
     21      Positive Effect                       22   31    19     21   11    26        31
     53      Negative Effect                       55   45    60     51   51    52        42
     25      Not Much Effect                       22   24    20     27   35    22        26
      1      Don't Know/Refused                     1    0     1      1    3     0         1
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        c. Buyouts of local newspapers by
            large newspaper chains
      7      Positive Effect                        7    8     6      7   11     5        10
     73      Negative Effect                       73   79    70     73   62    77        81
     18      Not Much Effect                       17   10    22     18   24    16         9
      2      Don't Know/Refused                     3    3     2      2    3     2         0
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        d. Buyouts of news organizations by
           diversified corporations
      6      Positive Effect                        8   13     6      3    3     4         3
     73      Negative Effect                       71   68    71     75   73    74        84
     18      Not Much Effect                       19   16    22     18   21    19        12
      3      Don't Know/Refused                     2    3     1      4    3     3         1
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        e. The emergence of online-only news
            pages and magazines
     58      Positive Effect                       61   58    61     55   49    56        58
     19      Negative Effect                       20   21    19     18   22    16        25
     20      Not Much Effect                       16   16    18     24   24    26        17
      3      Don't Know/Refused                     3    5     2      3    5     2         0
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

3. How good a job does journalism do striking a balance between the two goals of what
audiences want to know and what's important for them to know?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     36      Excellent/Good                        37   39    37     35   40    34        38
              2    Excellent                        2    5     1      2    5     1         2
             34   Good                             35   34    36     33   35    33        36
     61      Fair/Poor                             60   58    61     62   60    62        62
             56   Only fair                        55   53    55     57   60    56        58
              5   Poor                              5    5     6      5    0     6         4
      3      Don't Know/Refused                     3    3     2      3    0     4         0
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100


4. In your opinion, to what extent do corporate owners influence news organizations'
decisions about which stories to cover or emphasize?
                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     39      A great deal/A fair amount            34   42    30     45   27    51        61
              9    A great deal                     5    5     4     13    3    16        17
             30   A fair amount                    29   37    26     32   24    35        44
     58      Not very much/Not at all              64   55    69     52   70    47        38
             54   Not very much                    60   47    67     48   65    43        38
              4    Not at all                       4    8     2      4    5     4         0
      3      Don't Know/Refused                     2    3     1      3    3     2         1
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

5. In your opinion, to what extent do advertising concerns influence news organizations'
decisions about which stories to cover or emphasize?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     28      A great deal/A fair amount            22   31    17     34    8    43        49
              5   A great deal                      3    5     2      7    0     9        11
             23   A fair amount                    19   26    15     27    8    34        38
     70      Not very much/Not at all              76   66    82     65   92    56        51
             60   Not very much                    66   50    75     54   73    47        43
             10   Not at all                       10   16     7     11   19     9         8
      2      Don't Know/Refused                     2    3     1      1    0     1         0
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100


Now, turning to another topic...
6. In your experience, do journalists sometimes purposely avoid covering certain stories
that they believe are truly newsworthy?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     37      Yes                                   31   40    25     41   24    42        55
     62      No                                    68   60    75     57   73    57        43
      1      Don't Know/Refused                     1    0     0      2    3     1         2
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

ASK Q.7 THRU Q.11 ONLY IF ANSWERED "YES" (Q.6 = 1), IF ANSWERED "NO"(Q.6 = 2 or 3), SKIP TO Q.12
7. What would you say is the main reason why journalists sometimes avoid covering stories they
believe are newsworthy? (OPEN-END)

BASED ON THOSE WHO THINK JOURNALISTS SOMETIMES PURPOSELY AVOID NEWSWORTHY STORIES [N=105]:
                                                                                Investigative
   Total                                                 National      Local      Journalists
     35      CORPORATE MANAGEMENT RESTRAINTS(NET)           26           42            47
             15  Bosses/Editors/Management wouldn't support 14           16            33
              7  Advertising concerns                        2           10             2
              6  Corporate concerns                          0           10            12
              4  Bosses/Managers would retaliate             0            6             2
              3  Internal politics                           5            2             2
              2  Corporate anger                             2            2             0
              2  Never get published (unspecified)           0            3             2 
              2  All other corporate/management concerns     2            2             0
     30      PERSONAL CONSTRAINTS (NET)                     30           29            27
             16  Lack of time/resources                     16           16            16
              5  Laziness                                    2            6             8
              1  Priorities                                  2            0             2
             10  All other personal constraints              9           10             2
     17      AUDIENCE READERSHIP (NET)                      21           15             8
             10  No audience/Not marketable audience        14            6             2
              3  Ratings competition                         5            2             4
              3  Fear of angering audience                   0            5             0
              2  Political correctness                       2            2             2
              1  Fear of angering group being covered        2            0             0
      8       STORY LIMITS (NET)                             9            6             4
              7  Too complex                                 7            6             4
              1  Dull                                        2            0             0
      3       Other                                          5            2             8
     23       No response                                   23           23            18
                                                         (n=43)       (n=62)        (n=49)

8. Typically, do journalists...
BASED ON THOSE WHO THINK JOURNALISTS SOMETIMES PURPOSELY AVOID NEWSWORTHY STORIES [N=105]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     22      decide to avoid these stories on their own     16           26            14
 
             decide to avoid these stories based on how
             they believe their bosses would respond
     24      to the stories?                                35           17            31

             get signals from their bosses to avoid
     30      these stories?                                 28           31            35

     13      some other reason                              14           13            10

     11      Don't Know/Refused                              7           13             8
     100                                                   100          100           100


ASK Q.9 THRU Q.11 ONLY IF ANSWERED "JOURNALISTS GET SIGNALS" (Q.8 = 3):
9.When journalists get signals from their bosses to avoid some stories...
What types of signals do they get? (OPEN-END) 

BASED ON THOSE WHO SAY JOURNALISTS GET SIGNALS FROM BOSSES TO AVOID STORIES [N=31]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     35      DIRECT (NET)                                  33           37            41
             16 Don't Cover                                17           16            24
                Overt instructions about what kinds of
             10  stories to cover/avoid                    8            11             0
             10  Pretty clear                              8            11            18
     32      INDIRECT (NET)                               25            37            65
             13  Lack of interest in stories/
                 Stories don't get published/aired        17            11            41
             13  Yawns/Hemming/Hawing                      8            16            18
              3  Banter/Jokes                              0             5             6
              3  Failure to free time/resources            0             5            18
              3  Pleas for different stories               0             5             0
                 Warnings of declining budget/
             10  No support in response to story           8            11             0
              6  Dull                                      8             5             0
              6  Ratings/No audience                      17             0            12
              3  Not newsworthy                            8             0             0
              3  Too expensive                             0             5             0
       3     No response                                   8             0             0 
 

10.     And what types of topics attract these signals? (OPEN-END)

BASED ON THOSE WHO SAY JOURNALISTS GET SIGNALS FROM BOSSES TO AVOID STORIES [N=31]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     26      TYPES (NET)                                   42           16            18
             13 Complicated/Complex/Hard                   25            5            12 
              6 Investigative                               8            5            12
              3 Thinking/Academic                           0            5             0
              3 Speciality stories/Narrowcast               8            0             0
     39      SUBJECTS (NET)                                33           42            41
             13 Politics                                    0           21            12
             10 Economic (general)                          8           11             0
              6 Financial (corporate power, consumer)       8            5            24
              6 International/Foreign affairs              17            0             6
              3 Domestic Issues                             0            5             0
              3 Poor                                        0            5            12
              3 Health/AIDS/Medical stories                 8            0             0
              3 Morality/Sex                                8            0             0
              3 Education                                   0            5             0
     16      POSSIBLE REACTIONS(NET)                        8           21             6
             16 Stories that could alienate advertisers     8           21             0
              3 Stories that could alienate local elites    0            5             0
              0 Stories that could alienate (general)       0            0             6
      3       Other                                         0            5             6
     26       No response                                  25           26            35 

11.  What topics are "safe subjects" that is, are least likely to attract these signals? (OPEN-END)

BASED ON THOSE WHO SAY JOURNALISTS GET SIGNALS FROM BOSSES TO AVOID STORIES [N=31]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     29      SUBJECTS (NET)                                33           26            41
             13 Health/AIDS                                25            5             0
             10 Economic (general)                          8           11            12
              6 Politics                                    8            5             6
              3 Financial                                   8            0             0
              3 Crime                                       0            5            24
              3 Government                                  0            5             6
              0 The Poor/Needy                              0            0             6
     23       TYPES (NET)                                  17           26            12
              13 Non-controversial/soft/puff                8           16             6
               3 Typical controversies                      8            0             0 
               3 Specialty stories/Narrowcast               0            5             0
               3 Stories that don't alienate advertisers    0            5             0
               0 Short/Simple                               0            0             6
      6       Other                                        17            0            12
     42       No response                                  33           47            41


ASK ALL:
12.     Here are some reasons for purposely avoiding truly newsworthy stories.  How often,
if ever, do you think the journalists you know avoid a newsworthy story because...

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
        a. the story is seen as too complicated
           for the average reader
     52      Commonplace/Sometimes                 62   63    61     43   41    45        59
             12   Commonplace                      15   10    15     10    6    12        11
             40   Sometimes                        47   53    46     33   35    33        48
     42      Rarely/Never                          35   34    38     48   54    48        31
             33   Rarely                           28   24    33     37   41    38        27
              9   Never                             7   10     5     11   13    10         4
      6      Don't Know/Refused                     3    3     1      9    5     7        10
     100                                            100  100   100    100  100   100       100

         b. the story is seen as important but dull
     77      Commonplace/Sometimes                 84   79    85     71   62    76        77
             27   Commonplace                      30   29    32     25   13    29        33
             50   Sometimes                        54   50    53     46   49    47        44
     20      Rarely/Never                          15   21    14     25   33    23        19
             16   Rarely                           13   21    10     20   25    19        13
              4   Never                             2    0     4      5    8     4         6
      3      Don't Know/Refused                     1    0     1      4    5     1         4
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        c. the story would hurt a reporter's
           relationship with a source
     42      Commonplace/Sometimes                 40   34    42     43   32    48        57
              6   Commonplace                       4    5     4      8    2    10         5
             36   Sometimes                        36   29    38     35   30    38        52
     54      Rarely/Never                          57   63    56     52   60    51        38
             45   Rarely                           46   42    48     45   46    47        30
              9   Never                            11   21     8      7   14     4         8
      4      Don't Know/Refused                     3    3     2      5    8     1         5
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        d. the story would draw attention to or
           worsen a community problem
     19      Commonplace/Sometimes                 13    8    13     23   27    23        27
              2   Commonplace                       1    3     0      3    0     5         1
             17   Sometimes                        12    5    13     20   27    18        26
     77      Rarely/Never                          83   89    82     72   68    76        69
             54   Rarely                           59   63    60     49   49    52        40
             23   Never                            24   26    22     23   19    24        29
      4      Don't Know/Refused                     4    3     5      5    5     1         4
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        e. the story might be ridiculed or 
           frowned on by other journalists
    38       Commonplace/Sometimes                 38   42    32     39   38    39        32
              7   Commonplace                       6   10     4      8    5     7        12
             31   Sometimes                        32   32    28     31   33    32        20
    58       Rarely/Never                          59   55    66     56   54    60        62
             39   Rarely                           39   29    47     37   40    38        37
             19   Never                            20   26    19     19   14    22        25
     4       Don't Know/Refused                     3    3     2      5    8     1         6
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        f. the story would be embarrassing or
           damaging to the financial interests
           of a news organization's owners or
           parent company
    35       Commonplace/Sometimes                 31   42    28     39   32    44        50
              6   Commonplace                       3    5     3      8    0    11        17
             29   Sometimes                        28   37    25     31   32    33        33
    61       Rarely/Sometimes                      67   58    72     55   60    55        44
             40   Rarely                           44   37    47     37   33    40        24
             21   Never                            23   21    25     18   27    15        20
     4       Don't Know/Refused                     2    0     0      6    8     1         6
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        g. the story would be embarrassing or
           damaging to a news organization's
           advertisers
    29       Commonplace/Sometimes                 23   34    19     35   24    39        40
              6   Commonplace                       3    2     3      9    3    12        11
             23   Sometimes                        20   32    16     26   21    27        29
    66       Rarely/Never                          75   66    80     59   65    60        54
             44   Rarely                           47   40    51     41   32    45        36
             22   Never                            28   26    29     18   33    15        18
     5       Don't Know/Refused                     2    0     1      6   11     1         6
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        h. the story would be embarrassing or
           damaging to friends or associates
           of a news organization's owners
    24       Commonplace/Sometimes                 18   18    16     29   16    32        30
              4   Commonplace                       2    2     2      5    0     6         9
             20   Sometimes                        16   16    14     24   16    26        21
    72       Rarely/Never                          79   82    82     66   79    67        63
             46   Rarely                           46   48    48     46   52    47        39
             26   Never                            33   34    34     20   27    20        24
     4       Don't Know/Refused                     3    0     2      5    5     1         7
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        i. the story would be embarrassing or
           damaging to friends of a news
           organization's editors
    20       Commonplace/Sometimes                 15   18    15     24   16    28        31
              3   Commonplace                       2    2     2      4    0     6         3
             17   Sometimes                        13   16    13     20   16    22        28
    75       Rarely/Never                          79   74    83     71   79    71        62
             46   Rarely                           48   37    53     44   49    42        38
             29   Never                            31   37    30     27   30    29        24
     5       Don't Know/Refused                     6    8     2      5    5     1         7
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100       100

        j. the story would be damaging to a
           journalist's career
    38       Commonplace/Sometimes                 41   39    42     35   38    34        37
              5   Commonplace                       6    5     6      4    0     5         7
             33   Sometimes                        35   34    36     31   38    29        30
    55       Rarely/Never                          52   58    53     59   57    65        59
             36   Rarely                           35   40    36     38   35    41        39
             19   Never                            17   18    17     21   22    24        20
     7       Don't Know/Refused                     7    3     5      6    5     1        4
    100                                           100  100   100    100  100   100      100

IF ANSWERED "COMMONPLACE" OR "SOMETIMES" IN Q.12 ITEM  f (Q.12f  = 1 OR 2), ASK: 
13.     When journalists avoid stories because they would be embarrassing or damaging to
the financial interests of a news organization's owners or parent company, do journalists...

BASED ON THOSE WHO SAID JOURNALISTS AVOID STORIES BECAUSE THEY WOULD BE DAMAGING
TO FINANCIAL INTERESTS OF NEWS ORGANIZATION'S OWNERS [N=101]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
      8     decide to avoid these stories on their own?     2           12             4

            decide to avoid these stories based on how
            they believe their bosses would respond to
     30     the stories?                                   24           35            33

            get signals from their bosses to avoid
     45     these stories?                                 49           43            56

      9     some other reason                              16            3             7

      8     Don't Know/Refused                              9            7             0
     100                                                  100          100           100
                                                        (n=43)       (n=58)        (n=45)

IF ANSWERED "COMMONPLACE" OR "SOMETIMES" IN Q.12 ITEM g (Q.12g  = 1 OR 2), ASK: 
14.     When journalists avoid stories because they would be embarrassing or damaging to
a news organization's advertisers, do journalists...

BASED ON THOSE WHO SAID JOURNALISTS AVOID STORIES BECAUSE THEY WOULD BE DAMAGING
TO  NEWS ORGANIZATION'S ADVERTISERS [N=84]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
      4      decide to avoid these stories on their own?    6            2             6

             decide to avoid these stories based on how
             they believe their bosses would respond to
     24      the stories?                                  35            17            19

             get signals from their bosses to avoid
     57      these stories?                                44           65            67

      6      some other reason                              9            4             5

      9      Don't Know/Refused                             6           12             3
     100                                                  100          100           100
                                                        (n=32)       (n=52)        (n=36)

ASK ALL:
15.     How often, if ever, do journalists mistakenly think a story is killed or buried
because it is embarrassing or damaging to the financial interests of a news organization's
owners or parent company, when it is actually killed or buried because it is a not a good
news story?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     58      Commonplace/Sometimes                 58   66    59     58   62    61        67
             10   Commonplace                       9   13     9     10   16     7        12
             48   Sometimes                        49   53    50     48   46    54        55
     34      Rarely/Never                          36   32    38     32   30    35        30
             29   Rarely                           29   21    33     28   30    29        28
             5    Never                             7   11     5      4    0     6         2
      8          Don't Know/Refused                 6    2     3     10    8     4         3
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

Now a few questions about  YOUR OWN experiences...
16.     Do you sometimes purposely avoid covering certain stories that you believe are
truly newsworthy?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     26      Yes                                   26   18    27     26    8    31        28
     69      No                                    70   82    71     69   89    68        69
      5      Don't Know/Refused                     4    0     2      5    3     1         3
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100


IF "YES" IN Q.16 (Q.16 = 1) , ASK Q.17 THRU 19: IF "NO" (Q.16 = 2 OR 9), SKIP TO Q.20
17.     What is the main reason why you sometimes avoid covering stories you believe are newsworthy? (OPEN-END)

BASED ON THOSE JOURNALISTS WHO SAID THEY THEMSELVES SOMETIMES PURPOSELY AVOID COVERING STORIES[N= 74]:
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     41      CONTENT CONSTRAINTS                           46           36            56
             20  Time pressures                            14           26            40
              7  Too complicated                           11            3             8
              7  Boring                                    11            3             4
              5  TV wrong medium                            6            5             8
              4  Audience not interested                    9            0             0
              1  Competition                                0            3             0
              1  Not newsworthy                             0            3             0
     34       MANAGEMENT CONSTRAINTS                       29           38            24
              19 Editor/Boss doesn't want                  20           18            16
               9 Past experience/tired of fight             3           15             4
               3 Concern about ownership                    3            3             0
               1 Internal politics                          3            0             0
               1 Career concerns                            0            3             0
               0 Concern about advertisers                  0            0             4
      5       PERSONAL REASONS                              9            3             4
               1 Not interested in story                    3            0             0
               3 Misc. personal reasons                     3            3             0
               1 Laziness                                   3            0             4
      8       Other                                         6           10            16
     15       No response                                  14           15             4
                                                        (n=35)       (n=39)        (n=25)

18.     Typically, do you..
BASED ON THOSE JOURNALISTS WHO SAID THEY THEMSELVES SOMETIMES PURPOSELY AVOID COVERING STORIES[N= 74]: Investigative
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
     38      decide to avoid these stories on their own?   43           33            32

             decide to avoid these stories based on how
             they believe their bosses would respond to
     15      the stories?                                  11           18            28 

             get signals from their bosses to avoid
     19      these stories?                                17           21            20

      9      some other reason                              9           10             8

     19      Don't Know/Refused                            20           18            12
     100                                                  100          100           100


19.How often, if ever, do you avoid a truly newsworthy story because..[N=72]
                                                                               Investigative
   Total                                                National      Local      Journalists
        a. the story would be seen as too complicated 
            for the average reader
     40      Often/Sometimes                               44           37            26
              7  Often                                      9            5             0
             33  Sometimes                                 35           32            26
     60      Rarely/Never                                  56           63            74
             35   Rarely                                   32           37            57
             25   Never                                    24           26            17
      0      Don't Know/Refused                             0            0             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        b. the story would be seen as important but dull
     58      Often/Sometimes                               65           53            52
             12  Often                                     15           11             4
             46  Sometimes                                 50           42            48
     40      Rarely/Never                                  32           47            48
             28  Rarely                                    26           29            31
             12  Never                                      6           18            17
      2      Don't Know/Refused                             3            0             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        c. the story would hurt your relationship
           with a source
     18      Often/Sometimes                               15           21            17
              0  Often                                      0            0             0
             18  Sometimes                                 15           21            17
     79      Rarely/Never                                  85           74            74
             42  Rarely                                    47           37            26
             37  Never                                     38           37            48
      3      Don't Know/Refused                             0            5             9
     100                                                  100          100           100

        d. the story would draw attention to or
           worsen a community problem
     12      Often/Sometimes                                9           16             4
              1  Often                                      0            3             0
             11  Sometimes                                  9           13             4
     85      Rarely/Never                                  88           82            96
             24  Rarely                                    26           21            31
             61  Never                                     62           61            65
      3      Don't Know/Refused                             3            2             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        e. the story might be ridiculed or frowned
           on by other journalists
      7      Often/Sometimes                                6            8             9
              3  Often                                      0            5             0
              4  Sometimes                                  6            3             9
     92      Rarely/Never                                  94           89            91
             25  Rarely                                    23           26            13
             67  Never                                     71           63            78
      1      Don't Know/Refused                             0            3             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        f. the story would be embarrassing or damaging
           to the financial interests of your news
           organization's owners or parent company
     18      Often/Sometimes                               12           24            13
              3  Often                                      3            3             0
             15  Sometimes                                  9           21            13
     81      Rarely/Never                                  88           74            87
             21  Rarely                                    12           29            26
             60  Never                                     76           45            61
      1      Don't Know/Refused                             0            2             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        g. the story would be embarrassing or damaging
           to your news organization's advertisers
     13      Often/Sometimes                                6           18            18
              2  Often                                      0            2             0
             11  Sometimes                                  6           16            18
     86      Rarely/Never                                  94           79            78
             15  Rarely                                    15           16            22
             71  Never                                     79           63            56
      1      Don't Know/Refused                             0            3             4
     100                                                  100          100           100

        h. the story would be embarrassing or damaging
           to friends or associates of your news
           organization's owners
      8      Often/Sometimes                                6           10            13
              3  Often                                      3            2             0
              5  Sometimes                                  3            8            13
     90      Rarely/Never                                  94           87            83
             22  Rarely                                    12           32            13
             68  Never                                     82           55            70
      2      Don't Know/Refused                             0            3             4
     100                                                  100          100           100

        i. the story would be embarrassing or damaging
           to friends or associates of your editors
      8      Often/Sometimes                                6           11             9
              3  Often                                      3            3             0
              5  Sometimes                                  3            8             9
     86      Rarely/Never                                  85           86            91
             25  Rarely                                    15           35            22
             61  Never                                     70           51            69
      6      Don't Know/Refused                             9            3             0
     100                                                  100          100           100

        j. the story would be damaging to your career
     11      Often/Sometimes                                6           16            18
              1  Often                                      0            3             0
             10  Sometimes                                  6           13            18
     86      Rarely/Sometimes                              94           79            82
             47  Rarely                                    59           35            32
             39  Never                                     35           44            50
      3      Don't Know/Refused                             0            5             0
     100                                                  100          100           100
                                                        (n=34)       (n=38)        (n=23)

ASK ALL:
20.     Have you ever softened the tone or angle of a news story on behalf of the
interests of your news organization?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     23      Yes                                   17   26    15     29   33    32        23
     69      No                                    77   71    84     61   62    66        69
      8      Don't Know/Refused                     6    3     1     10    5     2         8
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

21.     Have you ever been asked or told to avoid a newsworthy story because it was too
complicated or not interesting but suspected the actual reason was the story might be
embarrassing or damaging to the financial interests of your news organization's owners
or parent company?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     13      Yes                                    4   10     2     20   13    26        34
     80      No                                    90   90    97     71   87    72        58
      7      Don't Know/Refused                     6    0     1      9    0     2         8
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100

22 Have you ever been criticized or felt pressure from superiors after a news story you
worked on came out because that story was seen as embarrassing or damaging to the
financial interests of your news organization's owners or parent company?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     19      Yes                                   17   21    17     20   27    20        19
     74      No                                    77   79    82     71   73    78        72
      7      Don't know/Refused                     6    0     1      9    0     2         9
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100


Finally, a few background questions so we can describe the types of journalists who took
part in this survey...
23.     What type of news organization do you work for?

                                                    National           Local        Investigative
   Total                                         Total Exec Journ  Total Exec Journ   Journalists
     51      Newspaper                             29   21    35     70   79    73        62
      3      Magazine                               6    5     7      1    0     1         6
      4      News Service                           9    8    10      1    3     0         3
     26      Television                            36   40    36     17   16    21        16
      4      Radio                                  9   10     9      1    0     1         0
      4      Internet                               5   13     2      2    5     2         0
      1      Other                                  1    3     1      0    0     1         4
      7      Don't Know/Refused                     5    0     0      8    0     1         9
     100                                          100  100   100    100  100   100       100
Background
Background
Table of Contents
  • Questionnaire